I was recently thinking about when a detail is a Chekov's gun and when it's just, y'know, part of scene setting or world building. I was thinking this because my mind was pinging on things that I was sure were being placed in the story to be picked up later (the story was Mr. Penumbra's 24-Hour Bookstore, and the details in question *were* picked up again, but not in the way I expected), and yet not all details are there to be used later. To take an example that pops into my head, in Ann Leckie's Imperial Radch series, it's culturally significant that people in the Radch cover their hands and think uncovered hands are rude/indecent, and that fact is used to show differences in people's attitudes and statuses, but the fact of gloves and wearing them or not never gets used in a plot-defining moment. I don't know; maybe that's too general a plot detail to be a potential Chekov's gun. But even an actual gun on the wall might not be a Chekov's gun, it seems to me. It could be there just to establish the atmosphere of a hunting lodge, say. Or maybe it's a treasured memento of a grandfather who was a great hunter, and the storyteller is using it as a way to show how the protagonist feels about the grandfather, etc. etc.
Do you think you like it better if the Chekov's guns are unobtrusive and only reveal their Chekov-gunniness when they're picked up, or do you prefer to have an aura of menace around them from the start, so you wonder how and when they'll be picked up? Or does it depend? I was about to say that I think it shows more craft if you can't distinguish the Chekov's guns from the general scene setting until the moment comes, but now I'm not so sure.
Do you think you like it better if the Chekov's guns are unobtrusive and only reveal their Chekov-gunniness when they're picked up, or do you prefer to have an aura of menace around them from the start, so you wonder how and when they'll be picked up? Or does it depend? I was about to say that I think it shows more craft if you can't distinguish the Chekov's guns from the general scene setting until the moment comes, but now I'm not so sure.